New FutureLakes Report Demonstrates How “Critical Friends” Can Strengthen Lake Governance Across Europe

FutureLakes Deliverable 2.3 reveals how innovative stakeholder engagement approaches can foster more inclusive, collaborative, and effective lake governance.

Lake restoration is not only a technical or ecological challenge. It also depends on the ability of diverse stakeholders to work together, navigate competing interests, and build consensus around long-term environmental goals. A new FutureLakes report, Deliverable 2.3: Enhanced Platforms for Dialogue - Establishing and Evaluating “Critical Friends” Groups for More Inclusive Lake Governance, explores how a novel engagement approach helped strengthen participation and collaboration in three European lake restoration initiatives.

The report documents the implementation of Critical Friends groups at three FutureLakes Demonstration Sites: Lake Karla (Greece), Lake Vansjø (Norway), and the Kartuzy Lakes (Poland). The findings show that carefully designed stakeholder dialogue can improve governance processes, expand participation, and support more durable restoration outcomes.

Bringing New Voices into Lake Governance

The Critical Friends approach was developed to engage stakeholders who are often underrepresented in restoration planning and decision-making processes. These included representatives from NGOs, businesses, government agencies, different sectors, and stakeholders affected by lake management decisions but not traditionally involved in governance discussions.

Rather than serving as formal decision-makers, Critical Friends act as constructive partners who contribute external perspectives, challenge assumptions, identify overlooked issues, and encourage more inclusive thinking. By broadening participation, the approach aims to improve the quality, legitimacy, and long-term effectiveness of lake governance.

As environmental challenges become increasingly complex, involving a wider range of voices is essential for developing restoration strategies that are socially accepted, practically feasible, and ecologically effective.

Tailored Discussions for Local Challenges

The Critical Friends process was built upon stakeholder mapping undertaken earlier in the FutureLakes project and was carefully adapted to local conditions and priorities at each Demonstration Site.

Each site addressed a specific governance challenge:

  • Lake Karla, Greece focused on overcoming governance fragmentation and improving coordination among organisations and authorities.
  • Lake Vansjø, Norway examined stakeholder perspectives and collaboration opportunities related to nitrogen pollution and water quality management.
  • Kartuzy Lakes, Poland explored governance arrangements and collaboration needs following major restoration interventions.

Workshops involved between nine and twenty-one participants and were designed to encourage open dialogue, knowledge exchange, and collective problem-solving.

Nine Workshops, One Shared Goal

Between November 2025 and October 2026, the FutureLakes team organised a total of nine Critical Friends workshops, with three workshops held at each Demonstration Site.

Despite differences in governance systems, stakeholder cultures, and previous experience with participatory approaches, the results were remarkably consistent. Across all three locations, the workshops created safe and productive spaces for discussion, increased communication between stakeholder groups, and encouraged participants to consider challenges from multiple perspectives.

The process also helped identify locally relevant solutions while strengthening relationships among organisations that had not previously worked closely together.

Key Lessons for Inclusive Governance

The report highlights several factors that were critical to the success of the initiative.

First, effective stakeholder recruitment proved essential. Ensuring a diverse and balanced mix of participants helped broaden discussions and prevent governance conversations from being dominated by a limited number of interests.

Second, strong local facilitation played a central role in creating trust and maintaining productive dialogue. Facilitators helped navigate differing viewpoints while ensuring that all participants had opportunities to contribute.

Third, sustained engagement over time strengthened relationships and allowed discussions to evolve beyond immediate project concerns. The workshop series enabled participants to develop a deeper shared understanding of local challenges and opportunities.

Finally, flexibility emerged as a key principle. Activities were adapted to suit local contexts, priorities, and stakeholder needs, increasing both participation and relevance.

Building Networks Beyond the Project

While the report acknowledges challenges such as uneven participation levels and trade-offs between different stakeholder engagement objectives, the overall assessment is highly positive.

The Critical Friends groups helped to:

  • Expand stakeholder networks;
  • Strengthen relationships between organisations and sectors;
  • Increase mutual understanding among participants;
  • Improve dialogue around complex environmental challenges;
  • Establish foundations for continued collaboration after the conclusion of project activities.

Perhaps most importantly, the process demonstrated that inclusive governance is not simply about involving more people, but about creating meaningful opportunities for engagement that can influence how restoration challenges are understood and addressed.

A Model for Future Lake Restoration Initiatives

As lake restoration projects increasingly recognise the importance of social and governance dimensions, the FutureLakes Critical Friends approach offers a practical and adaptable model for stakeholder engagement.

The report concludes that the method has strong potential for replication in other lake restoration contexts across Europe. By combining structured dialogue, local knowledge, and diverse perspectives, Critical Friends groups can help bridge governance gaps, build trust among stakeholders, and support more resilient and inclusive restoration strategies.

Deliverable 2.3 demonstrates that successful lake restoration depends not only on ecological innovation, but also on the quality of the conversations, partnerships, and governance structures that support long-term environmental recovery.

Read the deliverable here